The “Without Prejudice” Principle: A Milestone in Settlement Negotiations

One of the most notable recent developments is the recognition of the “without prejudice” principle by Dubai courts. This concept, well-established in many common law jurisdictions, has now found its place in Dubai’s legal framework. In a landmark decision, the Dubai Court of Cassation upheld a ruling that communications made during settlement negotiations are inadmissible as evidence of a party’s liability.

The case in question involved a dispute over a cryptocurrency transaction. When the matter reached the Court of Appeal, it was determined that statements made during amicable settlement discussions should not be considered as evidence of liability. The Court of Cassation later affirmed this decision, emphasizing that unsuccessful settlement discussions are inadmissible in court proceedings.

This ruling marks a significant shift in the UAE’s approach to settlement negotiations. Historically, UAE laws did not explicitly provide for the “without prejudice” principle, and courts often considered the content of settlement communications as admissible evidence. The new stance encourages parties to engage in open and honest negotiations without fear that their statements might later be used against them in court. Implications for Commercial Dispute Resolution

The recognition of the “without prejudice” principle has far-reaching implications for commercial dispute resolution in Dubai and the UAE:

1. Encouraging Amicable Settlements: By protecting the confidentiality of settlement communications, the ruling fosters an environment conducive to open and honest negotiation. This may lead to an increase in amicable resolutions of disputes, reducing the burden on the court system.
2. Alignment with International Standards: This development brings Dubai’s legal practice closer to international standards, potentially making it a more attractive jurisdiction for foreign businesses and investors.
3. Enhanced Legal Certainty: The ruling provides greater clarity and certainty for parties engaged in settlement negotiations, allowing them to communicate more freely without the risk of their statements being used against them later.
4. Potential Legislative Changes: While this court decision is a significant step, there are calls for explicit legislative recognition of the “without prejudice” principle to solidify its status in UAE law.

Other Notable Legal Developments

Alongside the recognition of the “without prejudice” principle, Dubai’s legal landscape has seen other important changes:

1. Arbitration Costs: The Dubai Court of Cassation confirmed that under the ICC Rules, arbitral tribunals have the authority to award reasonable legal costs, including lawyers’ fees. This clarification is crucial for parties considering arbitration in Dubai. 

2. Conflict of Jurisdiction Tribunal: Dubai established a new Judicial Authority for Resolving Jurisdictional Conflicts between the Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC) and onshore Dubai courts. This development aims to streamline the resolution of jurisdictional disputes. 
3. Asymmetric Jurisdiction Clauses: In a separate ruling, the Dubai Court of Cassation held that unilateral options to arbitrate are invalid. This decision diverges from the approach taken in some other jurisdictions and may impact the drafting of dispute resolution clauses in commercial contracts.

Challenges and Future Outlook

While these developments represent significant progress, challenges remain. The UAE does not have a system of binding precedent, which means that the application of the “without prejudice” principle may not be uniform across all cases. Legal practitioners and parties involved in commercial disputes should remain cautious and clearly indicate when communications are intended to be without prejudice.

Looking ahead, there is potential for further legislative action to codify these principles into UAE law. This would provide even greater certainty and could further enhance Dubai’s position as a leading hub for international commercial dispute resolution.

Conclusion

The recent developments in Dubai’s legal landscape, particularly the recognition of the “without prejudice” principle, represent a significant step towards aligning with international legal standards. These changes are likely to have a positive impact on commercial dispute resolution in the region, encouraging more open settlement negotiations and potentially leading to more efficient resolution of disputes. As Dubai continues to evolve its legal framework, it strengthens its position as a key player in the global legal and business community.

Having said that, Contact Khairallah Advocates & Legal Consultants and benefit from our free 30-min legal consultation.

*Disclaimer: our blogs, law updates and FAQ’s are freely distributed for educational purposes and to showcase recent updates and regulations in the UAE’s framework.

If you have any questions and need assistance, contact us at our number or book an appointment online.